The Daily Technical #142: Is negative working capital a bad signal about a company's health?

Good morning. Welcome to the 142nd edition of The Daily Technical.

Now, you’re here for one reason, so let’s dive in.

First time reading? Sign up here.

OVERVIEW OF YESTERDAY’S QUESTION
What are the benefits of the industry beta approach?

The industry β approach looks at the β of a comparable peer group to the company being valued and then applies this beta to the target.

The benefits are that company-specific noise is eliminated, which refers to distorting events that could cause the correlation shown in its beta to be less accurate.

The peer-group derived beta is “normalized” since it takes the average of the unlevered betas of comparable businesses and then relevers it at the target capital structure of the company being valued.

The implied assumption is that the company's business risk will converge with its peer group over the long run.

This approach also enables one to arrive at an industry-derived beta for private companies that lack readily observable betas.

To perform a DCF analysis for a private company, the industry beta approach would be required as privately-held companies don't have readily observable betas.

Common Mistakes

1. Failing to identify truly comparable peers. Ensure your peer group shares similar operational, financial, and risk profiles to provide a meaningful industry beta, which enhances valuation accuracy.

2. Misinterpreting how normalization functions within the industry beta method. Understand that normalization involves averaging unlevered betas and adjusting them to reflect the target capital structure, ensuring you emphasize how this aligns with industry norms.

3. Assuming instant risk alignment with peers. Clarify that convergence happens over the long run, which requires patience and ongoing assessment rather than expecting immediate results.

TL;DR

• Uses peer group beta to eliminate company-specific noise, providing a clearer risk assessment.

• Averages unlevered peer betas, then adjusts to the target structure for a "normalized" beta.

• Assumes company risk aligns with peers long-term, improving beta accuracy.

• Essential for private companies, offering beta estimates for DCF analysis despite data gaps.

• Relies on industry norms, offering more reliable financial assessments.

TODAY’S QUESTION
Is negative working capital a bad signal about a company's health?

Type your answer here. Within 60 seconds you’ll have custom feedback in your inbox.

THAT’S A WRAP
Before You Go: Here’s How We Can Help!

Jobs: we’re tracking all open jobs for the classes of 2025 - 2028. Our list is updated daily. Check them out here

Mentorship: if you’re looking for 1:1 career mentorship, click here to book a free discovery call.

See you tomorrow,

Mike Lukasevicz
Founder @ HirePrep